Cartoons can be very dangerous territory. Traditionally, they are light-hearted drawings designed to make children laugh, but occasionally they cross the line, like the Danish cartoons designed to inflame the Muslim world or the many installments of "Family Circus" that promote child abuse.
President Barack Obama has set off a firestorm of potentially offensive cartoons, including yesterday's New York Post cartoon that appeared to some to compare Obama to a monkey, although others said it was just gently poking fun at the horrific mauling of a Connecticut woman. Wffew!
Here are a few of the more notable Obama cartoons that have sparked controversy:
The New Yorker "Terrorist Fist Jab" Cover
New Yorker cartoonist Barry Blitt says he created this magazine cover in July 2008 to mock people who accused Barack and Michelle Obama of being secret Muslims and Al Qaeda sympathizers. On the other hand, he drew a cartoon that showed the Obamas as secret Muslims and Al Qaeda sympathizers.
Last September, at something called the "Values Voters Summit," two attendees were found selling boxes of "Obama Waffles" to the likes of Lou Dobbs. The name seems to refer to Obama's "waffling" on certain issues, but the cartoon on the front also appears to compare Obama to Aunt Jemima, another well-known "waffler." The back and sides of the box also featured Obama in an Arab headress and a Mexican sombrero-- you think today's "values voter" will buy waffles with only one minstrel caricature on the box?
The Investor's Business Daily Jeremiah Wright Cartoon
The staid Investor's Business Daily is rarely a hotbed of racism, but this March 2008 cartoon by Michael Ramirez did show Obama "palling around" with a jive-talking Rev. Jeremiah Wright, wearing a shirt that says "Africa."
The "Suicide Obama" Cartoon
Robert Ariail, the political cartoonist for the Columbia, SC, State created this cartoon in April 2008 that appears to show Obama as a Muslim suicide bomber. Ariail said he was just making fun of the candidate's verbal gaffes, and perhaps his name. And also suicide bombing is hilarious. C'mon gang! Who's with him??
"Waterboard Barack Obama"
This one, posted on the website of the Sacramento Republican Party in October, describes that group's platform on the recent housing and credit crisis.
Voters are in a sour mood both about President Obama and Congress, with a plurality disapproving of Obama's job performance and a significant percentage saying that if the 2010 elections were held...
Oscar Goodman, the mayor of Las Vegas, has a message for President Obama: Stop using us as a punch line -- and don't let the door hit you on your way out.
The president took an inadvertent swipe at...
Politics Daily columnist and Daily FLOTUS writer Lynn Sweet appeared on the "UpFront with Tony Cox" radio program on Saturday to discuss the visit that she and a small group of reporters had with...
This supposed racism is in the mind of the beholder.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (2)
longwalker
4:26PM Feb 19th 2009
Of your five cartoons, I was only able to vote on the first three. The remaining two appear to be locked. However, on the first three, I noticed that most responders do not believe that the cartoons are racist. Better luck next time!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (2)
mattemmer
5:29PM Feb 19th 2009
How can anyone in their right minds believe that any of these cartoons are not racist. I am ashamed that 71% of the voters believe that there is nothing wrong with a website that proudly displays that we should water board Barack Obama. This behavior should not be tolerated at all. We have worked hard for generations to reverse prejudice. It is a shameful step in the wrong direction to accept clearly racist imagery as allowable.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-4)
Joey
7:03PM May 14th 2009
You're absolutely right, the government should step in and completely sensor everything we say, write and post, it's not like this country was founded on the idea of free speech or anything like that. You left wingers will complain about anything, grow up.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (4)
brntrewesl
4:39PM Feb 19th 2009
All that racism, and the guy is half-white. His race is of no consequence, his inexperience, his far-left beliefs and the disastrous decisions during his first month in office should concern every thinking American!
He made a promise of “The most ethical Administration of all time” followed by Four tax cheats selected as Cabinet members and top advisors.
He made a promise of “Total transparency with five days to review all important legislation” followed by the most expensive “Stimulus” legislation in history rushed through over a weekend. He made a promise of “No Lobbyists in my Administration” followed by eleven Cabinet and top advisors given waivers.
DJIA down 2160 points since election day.
The Dems bought B.O.*, but we all get to pay for him. Nice job, libs. Great start!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (7)
Mike Stewart
4:48PM Feb 19th 2009
she just a PRESIDENT thats all... Mindless idiots
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-2)
dr jay
5:02PM Feb 19th 2009
I'm with the majority on most of these -- they're not racist, just obnoxious, which is the job of a political cartoon, and in some cases stupid. But the Post cartoon is obnoxious, stupid, *and* probably racist. "Oh, there's a news story about a killer chimp. What an opportunity for a cartoon about Obama." Excuse me?
To be fair, plenty of white Presidents, from at least Lincoln through W, have been compared to "lower" primates at one time or another. But it's a long-standing racial slur as well, so it's hard to believe that *doesn't* enter into its use against Obama.
Likewise the "waffles," where I disagree with the plurality but it's a close vote. Plenty of Presidents and other politicians, of all races, have been called wafflers. But here you have not just one but three ethnic stereotypes. I guess I can imagine a white President presented that way, but only one whose supporters described him as "the first black President," and/or whose opponents (some of them) characterized him as a "N.....-lover." Either of which would make it racist in that case, too.
The New Yorker cover, of course, was a parody of *other* people's stereotypes of the Obamas. So it doesn't indicate any racism on the part of the cartoonist.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-1)
littlejohn
5:03PM Feb 19th 2009
These poll results are disturbing. Clearly someone linked to this post on a right-wing website.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-2)
dr jay
5:06PM Feb 19th 2009
Racist or not, of course, in the age of the Danish Muhammad cartoons (and the response thereto) I have to add that people have every right to create and publish them. And other people have every right to protest them peacefully, etc. Which the people I saw outside the News Corp. HQ on my way to lunch were doing, and at least some of the the anti-Danish "protesters" were not.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
dr jay
5:09PM Feb 19th 2009
>Clearly someone linked to this post on a >right-wing website.
Either that, littlejohn, or the left-wingers (and centrists, and whoever else) responding have enough sense to distinguish between "obnoxious" and "racist." Not every unfavorable thing that anyone says about a person of another race is racist.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (1)
bonbon
5:17PM Feb 19th 2009
apparently more people think they are not racists, than those that do
RATE THIS COMMENT: (1)
missmalevolent
6:06PM Feb 19th 2009
I'm a black woman and the only one of these I find questionable is the last one...Obama/Osama BS. And even in that is more tacky then racist.
Honestly the "sensitivity" about "race" is garbage...this is just a tool. Just like criticizing George Bush Jr. made you "unpatriotic" so now, does criticizing Obama make you a "racist".
When are people going to wake the fuck up to these shenanigans.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (1)
Ryan
6:17PM Feb 19th 2009
Not Racist.
Just Funny!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (6)
Fabricio
6:19PM Feb 19th 2009
Racism, hate, and discrimination: are among the tenets of christianity.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-5)
Thomas
6:35PM Feb 19th 2009
fact is , it is IGNORANCE that lead people to doing things that they THINK is intelligent, all be it hateful. They will bring down a whole business along with their stupidity. Seems They rather live the rest of they're life out as Bush has set the economy. There is at least hope in hearing the truth come from the blessed words of hope from President Obama's Vocal cords. It is evident that there are a few people that would rather live in hell then live amongst true humanity ( all people regardless of color). Live and Love.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-2)
Ryan
6:42PM Feb 19th 2009
Obama is a Liar.
Truth and Hope my ass.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (7)
CJ
6:50PM Feb 19th 2009
Ryan Darlin - play nice. Have a great night. Cyndi
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
ELLEN DUGGAN
6:58PM Feb 19th 2009
If you ask us to vote let us vote our way. Don't block the way we vote because it isn't the way you want us to vote.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
lolabull
7:23PM Feb 19th 2009
I don't really care that people call me a racist because I think Obama is a horrible choice to lead this country. I didn't even notice he was black until the liberals and democrats made such a big deal about it. And Thomas, I assume your supceptible to "the chill" up your leg like so many other deciples when they hear the smooth sounds of Mr. Obama? Do you have any thoughts or ideas of your own concerning any other part of your life, or do you just follow the flow of ignorance there as well?
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-1)
Ryan
7:46PM Feb 19th 2009
I'm proud that we have our first half white president!