Download the Politics Daily Toolbar
Our new toolbar integrates the latest news and analysis into your Web browser and installs in seconds. Download it now!

Politics DailyPolitics Daily

  • HOME
  • ABOUT
  • COLUMNISTS
  • TOPICS
  • THE CAPITOLIST
  • WOMAN UP
  • DAILY FLOTUS
  • JUST IN
  • THE CRAM
  • CONTACT
  • Inside Politics Daily

    Archbishop to Obama: Look Past 'Strident Outcries' Over ND Visit

    Posted:
    05/14/09
    Though dozens of his brother bishops have said they were "scandalized'' or "in shock and deep distress'' that our pro-choice president will speak and be honored at the University of Notre Dame this weekend, retired Archbishop John R. Quinn of San Francisco has let President Obama know that not all pro-life Catholics -- or even all strongly pro-life Catholic prelates – see things that way.
    Get the new
    PD toolbar!

    "I am writing as a Catholic Bishop to offer a different voice from the often strident outcries over your forthcoming visit to Notre Dame,'' Quinn said in the April 22 letter. Today, he provided a copy of it to PoliticsDaily.com. Quinn, a former president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, went on to praise Obama as a history-making role model, an inspiring family man and a thoughtful person. Between the lines, his message was, Don't let those guys waving signs get you down.

    In a phone interview on Thursday, I asked Quinn why he had written to the president – especially since at age 80, he so rarely speaks out these days: "No, I really don't,'' he said, "but I just thought there needed to be a positive note in this whole discourse.''

    Though he does not agree with Obama on abortion rights, "it's not that the only issue involved is the life issue, though certain people have spoken very vociferously and focused only on that one point.'' (LifeSiteNews.com lists 76 bishops who have reportedly opposed Obama's "invitation and award'' at ND's graduation this Sunday, but not all those on the list think the president ought to be disinvited.)

    Quinn said he was puzzled that "there was not this outcry when the candidate Obama went to Xavier and the bishop there didn't speak out,'' or when French President Nicolas Sarkozy was honored at St. John Lateran in Rome, for that matter. Obama spoke at Xavier University's commencement in 2006, and Sarkozy, who also favors abortion rights, was made honorary canon of St. John Lateran in December 2007.

    The archbishop said he had not heard back from the president, and wasn't waiting by the mailbox. "But I hope he feels some encouragement from what I said, and knows that some of us see some very positive features even though we retain some differences.''
    The President
    The White House
    Washington, D. C. 20500

    Mr. President,

    I am writing as a Catholic Bishop to offer a different voice from the often strident outcries over your forthcoming visit to Notre Dame University. I acknowledge certain critical differences between us, especially on the issue of abortion. But without minimizing the gravity of these issues, I want to state several things, which I believe of major importance at this time.

    First, I am personally deeply gratified by the election of an African American as President of the United States and I share the jubilation of many Americans and in particular of many African American Catholics in the United States over your election. It is significant that the Vatican newspaper compared your election with the fall of the Berlin Wall and I recall that the Pope personally offered his congratulations to you.

    I believe it important to acknowledge the fine example you have given in your married life and in your love and devotion to your children. The ideal of stable family life has long been a focus of interest for the Catholic Church. This, together with your frequent call for personal responsibility, is a great contribution to our nation.

    It strikes me that you have shown a measured, thoughtful approach to issues of public concern and your ability to listen to and weigh views different from your own is an asset to the discharge of your high responsibilities. This admirable quality inspires hope for further dialog on issues over which there are major differences.

    Mr. President, I address this letter to you not to deal with matters of policy or legislation, but simply to wish you great blessings and to assure you of my prayer that your service as President will bring lasting benefits to all Americans who, with you, cherish the ideal of "liberty and justice for all."

    Most sincerely yours,

    +John R. Quinn
    Former Archbishop of San Francisco



    Follow PoliticsDaily On Facebook and Twitter,
    and download the new Politics Daily toolbar!

    Melinda Henneberger

    Melinda Henneberger is the editor-in-chief of PoliticsDaily.com. She spent 10 years as a reporter for the New York Times, in the paper’s Washington and Rome bureaus... more

    Contact Melinda Henneberger

    subscribe to: RSS email: Melinda Henneberger

    Related Articles

    Related Articles

    • Obama Gets Failing Grades from Gun Control Group

      20 days ago

      A leading advocacy group has given President Obama an "F" for what it calls his failure to take significant steps to advance gun control laws. The Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence endorsed...

    • Obama, Bush and Clinton Pen Essays Calling for Help in Haiti

      22 days ago

      In the cover story of this week's issue of Newsweek, President Obama outlines the aid he is calling for in Haiti, writing that "in times of tragedy, the United States of America steps forward and...

    • Is Obama Moving Off-Base?

      29 days ago

      In an attempt to placate right-wing voters in Arizona, Sen. John McCain, who is up for reelection this year and might face a fierce challenger in the Republican primary, released a radio ad last week...

    • Happening Right Now

       
    Politics Daily on Facebook

    Other News