Welcome to a new feature here at the Capitolist called "Who Is...?" where we give you a just-the-facts-ma'am rundown about a person in the news you should know about. Never again will you be at a party or innocently hanging out on the sidelines of a soccer game only to get stumped by a better-informed neighbor asking, "What do you think about x?" D'oh!
So bring on the summer BBQ circuit, fellow Capitolists. Casual conversation will never be the same again...
First up: "Who is Sonia Sotomayor?"
*Sonia Sotomayor is one of six potential nominees on the short list of Barack Obama's choices to replace Justice David Souter on the Supreme Court.
*She is currently a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals.
*Sotomayor once said that, as a child, she voraciously read Nancy Drew mysteries and wanted to be a detective like the brainy heroine. Subsequent episodes of Perry Mason made Sotomayor think life as a lawyer might be a better gig.
*Sotomayor graduated with highest honors from Princeton and with distinction from Yale Law School. She also married at Princeton, but divorced seven years later and had no children.
*After Yale Law, she worked as an assistant D.A. in New York City, and then went into private practice for seven years, making partner after three.
*In 1991, President George H.W. Bush appointed Sotomayor as a New York District Judge.
*In 1998, President Bill Clinton appointed her to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, but only after a year-long delay in the Senate confirmation process.
*Financially, she's no Warren Buffett (but who is?). The Washington Post reported she earns $179,500 per year as a judge, but has virtually no assets, including no stock holdings.
*A controversial video has become a lightening rod for her critics. At a 2005 Duke University panel, Sotomayor differentiated between the District Court and the Court of Appeals. She noted that facts tend to drive the decisions at the District level, but joked that the "Court of Appeals is where policy is made." Here's the clip:
Sen. Orin Hatch, a senior member of the Judiciary Committee, said the video is a "problem" for Sotomayor.
For serious analysis of Sotomayor's judicial record, check out the SCOTUS blog, one of our favorites. Otherwise, stay tuned to the Capitolist for other "Who is?" features on SCOTUS picks and notable names in the news.
Patricia Murphy writes "The Capitolist" column for PoliticsDaily.com. She is the founder of Citizen Jane Politics, a non-partisan website for women... more
My writing teacher and friend Elizabeth Christman, who wore a spiffy new suit and hat on the first day of every semester and was one of the finest humans ever, died last week at age 96. To be honest,...
With the publication of today's main story by Adam Zagorin and Michael Smallberg, Politics Daily is launching its new investigative reporting unit.
Our investigative coverage, dedicated to the...
Sonia Sotomayor was responsible for supervising judge Rosemary Pooler when Pooler was a District judge. That is, complaints about misconduct were to be handled by judges on the United States second circuit Court of Appeals, where Sonia Sotomayor was a judge. A complaint was made about Rosemary Pooler. The complaint centered on Rosemary Pooler taking on a case where Rosemary Pooler and her daughter had direct business dealings with one of the litigants and which business dealings had turned sour. The litigant was bringing to the attention of the district court, alleged misconduct by Anthony Cardona, Thomas Mercure, of the Supreme Court of New York Appellate Division Third Department. The alleged misconduct included misstating or making misleading statements about the law and facts of a case. The matter was essentially ignored by Judith Kaye of the Court of Appeals and thus the case went to Rosemary Pooler of the District court. Rosemary Pooler, who should have recused herself as the case involved someone who had business dealings with her and her daughter, also misstated the facts, but different facts which would allow dismissal of a complaint of misconduct and leave the State judges in the clear. Thus in the end, one judge after another provided the legal cover for others.
It is now up to Sonia Sotomayor to explain why she did little or nothing to investigate the complaint against Rosemary Pooler, which was the domain of the second circuit court. The people of the United States deserve an explanation before we place Sonia Sotomayor on the United States Supreme Court.