Does Bill O'Reilly have blood on his hands in the murder of late-term abortion doctor George Tiller? To hear many left-leaning websites tell it, there's no real question. One of O'Reilly's regular targets, the Daily Kos, has put together a video montage of the dozens of segments O'Reilly has aired accusing Tiller of "executing babies" for "no reason whatsoever" in a Nazi-style "death mill."
But did O'Reilly's vitriol over Tiller's profession really incite the likes of anti-government activist Scott Roeder, the suspect in the murder? After all, O'Reilly -- though he was adamant that Tiller's actions amounted to nothing less than mass murder -- never actually directed anybody to go out and shoot him.
Here's O'Reilly Monday night, taking aim at those who would try to link him with this terrible crime:
This raises an interesting point about the power that entertainment has over those who consume it. O'Reilly himself often makes the case that there is a causal line to be drawn from entertainer to consumer, most notably as exemplified by gangsta rap. Indeed, for years many people on the right (and some on the left) have sought to hold heavy-metal groups accountable for crimes they believed were caused by listening to the groups' music. One wonders if those people will hold O'Reilly to that same standard.
As to the matter of late-term abortion, Andrew Sullivan has been posting some eye-opening stories from his readers who have undergone the procedure. What they make clear is that not everyone who has a late-term abortion (in one of the three facilities in the U.S. where they are performed) does so lightly.
The only ones with blood on thier hands is Tiller and the nut that killed him. Just think of how many babies this might save to grow up past 22 weeks.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (6)
neil
10:13AM Jun 2nd 2009
so tired of you pro lifers...your whole life is a vast contradictions...you want every baby to live..but you are for wars all over the globe that kills 100 thousands of people per year...how many of these un wanted babies have you guys adopted...you are against welfare..dso how are these poor women suppose to feed these kids...you are against birth control...
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-2)
Gregory Dittmer
10:28AM Jun 2nd 2009
roberts 9:47AM Jun 2nd 2009 Just think of how many babies this might save to grow up past 22 weeks. *********************************************************************** Just how many more fetuses do YOU think will gestate beyond 22 weeks now that the doctor in ONE of THREE clinics has been murdered?
To hear the so-called "Pro Lifers" tell it, there are hundreds of thousands of late term abortions every year. The FACT that only THREE clinics in the entire nation do late term abortions would suggest the lunatic fringe is off their rocker!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-1)
Michael
10:54AM Jun 2nd 2009
Well, it is comforting to know that those who have had a late-term abortion didn't "take it lightly". Whew....makes me feel better....doesn't do the baby much good, but hey.
No matter how hard they try, the left can't EVER justify this heinous act of barbarism. Late-term abortions performed as after-the-fact birth control or as an avoidance of "inconvenience" serve to nullify any claim we make to be a "civilized society".
The Pro Choice crowd is so adamant in their stance that they won't allow for a 24 hour waiting period between making an appointment and performing the procedure. These SAME people insisted that the NRA capitulate to a 3-day waiting period for firearms purchase to allow for "cooling off". The hypocrisy is mind-numbing.
The fact that when asked, the absolute majority of women who have had abortions said later on that they wish they had never had it done. The agony of terminating their own child was a horrific weight to bear, especially when they decide to have children later on. The Pro-Choice crowd will not recognize these women and basically disowns them, because it sees them as detrimental to "the cause".
Abortion in any form is disgusting and reprehensible, but late-term abortion is doubly so. It's time that we implement a 24 hour "cooling off" period for any women who are about to make the biggest mistake of their lives. Doing so will invariably save innocent lives and prevent many women from living lives of internal torment and guilt.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (2)
hobbsoldbg65
10:07AM Jun 2nd 2009
How foolish to suggest that O'reilly caused that nut case to kill Tiller. He has been a target for anti abortion zealots for years. He has been the target of bombs and was shot in the arms in the 80's. Did O'Reilly cause those incidents too even though he was not on the air then? Wise up you kool aid drinkers, as he would say, nice try but it won,t fly.Liberal really are mentally deranged.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (8)
sandsnnydz
10:09AM Jun 2nd 2009
No blood on O'Reilly's Hands!!! and he sleeps well.....O'Reilly is a powerful man and he will hit back... he is getting too close on his investigations of the "Left-Wing Mafia"... George Soros /the Daily Kos who has been trying for YEARS (unsuccessfully) to stop O'Reilly from getting at the truth & it will not stop O'Reilly now!
.... rock on O'Reilly ..... the Factor is the number "1" Cable News Show for a reason!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
pjbl2223
10:14AM Jun 2nd 2009
Let the courts decide until then I will continue my lack of interest in right wing pundits.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
hammer
11:58AM Jun 2nd 2009
Why not let the people vote on it next federal election. That way the people will have spoken and not just nine individuals
RATE THIS COMMENT: (2)
tlc5300
10:17AM Jun 2nd 2009
Why can't this idiot shut the hell up? The banking crisis effects far more people and could lead this country into second place behind China. Is there day after day outrage over this? After all the villians would be New York left wingers O'Reilly's favorite target. The answer, of course is no, the topic of banking doesn't win the ratings battle. So the "Bully" has to weigh in on abortion, a hot button he knows will get attention. Now he's got all the attention he'll ever need, even it's the kind of attention he doesn't want. O'Reilly's the patron saint of the folks, the folks, etc...I'm the folks and Irish and I'm sick of this guy. He's become paranoid and mean, at a time when we need to be united, his show divides us.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-2)
zdboyer
10:18AM Jun 2nd 2009
ACORN is in a panic....the shredding machines are in high gear and working overtime.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (4)
The Chemist
10:20AM Jun 2nd 2009
"A journalist, musician and novelist"... Bullshit. David Knowles is a tool for the left.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (2)
Gregory Dittmer
10:18AM Jun 2nd 2009
If rap music and video games can be blamed on the violence in today's citys, then ABSOLUTELY, O'Reilly has blood on his hands!
While I am all for "free speech," I do believe people like O'Reilly and Limbaugh are treading a VERY fine line at best. Their constant ranting and railing incite their base and whips the so-called "Pro Lifers" into a frenzy of hate towards ANYONE that dare support the legal choice for women. What makes their rants any less than hate speech and inciting illegal actions? People have been charged with inciting a riot even thought they had no actual part in the resulting riot... how is O'Reilly any better than screaming fire in a crowded place?
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-2)
roberts
10:24AM Jun 2nd 2009
Neil there you go again spewing out stuff you know nothing about. You are right about one thing I am not for the murder of little babies or the killing of Tiller or people being killed in war.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (6)
welcommen obiwan
10:24AM Jun 2nd 2009
It seems to me that if you are going to make a big deal of journalism that has gone awry,then maybe you might mention that aticles by certain un-named media outlets have put our soldiers in harms way.That would at least be a proper lead into whatever theories you might have as to Mr.Oreilly's involvement with this.Of course if this is just a left vs. right thing then it has no merit to begin with.But irresponsible use of the media is a freedom and a constitutional protection right?Just like accusing a man of complicity in a crime he did not commit.If it is a law that you have the freedom to accuse then it must be right huh?Nevermind that the man who was murdered was a target way before these events made you bring your accusations which you disguise within a question.The maniacs out there are targeting the wrong badguys if you ask me,and you just get out your stir stick and watch it hit the fan.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (3)
nyyank37
10:32AM Jun 2nd 2009
why do we keep listening to this moron. pay no attention to him. and he'll eventually go away. fox should put a "this program is for entertainment only" disclaimer at the start of each of his shows.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-2)
neil
10:33AM Jun 2nd 2009
orielly,rush,etc..they all share blame..this is america,,people have a right to do what they want to there bodies...do you banning abortions would stop people from getting them..all it would do is drive up the cost and make it unsafe... doctors are doing what they are trained to do..its not the doctor fault that people are having unwanted children..they are doing there jobs..if we use the pro life logic..we should kill soldiers because during war time innocent people are killed..so we should start shooting our soldiers to stop those killing...
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-6)
jwr
10:35AM Jun 2nd 2009
I don't see it as a left verses right thing. I see it as a known LIAR bill orally aka Mr loofah, sitting home at night seeing tiller was killed and saying to himself "I might lose out on some money" I should blame it on the left. I believe bill punk orally is a rabid liar and is in it for only the money.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-5)
neil
10:42AM Jun 2nd 2009
i agree..bill oreilly and rush and beck...sit in those studios every day making millions of dollars per year ...spewing all that hatred ..but none of them have evry fought for this country..none of them every served one day dfor this country,,,they are liars and cowards..oh yeah hannity..when are you going to be man of your words and get waterboarded...oh yeah..he is another coward
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-2)
park457799
10:51AM Jun 2nd 2009
I understand Tiller performed 60,000 abortions during his career. You failed to mention this. I have no sympathy for Tiller. Sorry!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (6)
marahnatha
10:56AM Jun 2nd 2009
Bill O'Reilly never advocates taking another life, in fact if you watch him regularly & take his comments in context with his philosophy, you know he wouldn't want someone murdered. He doesn't even believe in the death penalty for rapists or murderers. He's not my favorite and I find many times I don't agree with him. People have no problem with the Tobacco Industry being called "murderers" for selling a legal substance, but this man who was such a "humanitarian" that he charged $5,000 for a $300 procedure is somehow lauded as a secular "saint." Until you're ready to accept accountability for the response of every person who reads your post here, don't throw stones. I wish everyone was as honest about what they believe so you know exactly what you're dealing with before you bother to welcome them into your life as a friend or as a public pundit.