When Cambridge Police Sgt. James Crowley and Harvard professor Henry Louis Gates Jr. gather at the White House on Thursday evening to have a beer with the guy who lives there, the suds-sharing will be what White House press secretary Robert Gibbs has dubbed "a teachable moment."
It will at least be a grand photo-op. White House reporters are poised for the event. Cable news shows are prepping for special coverage. ("Is the sergeant going in for a second beer, Ed?" "I don't know, Wolf.") But if this is indeed a teachable moment, the question is, what is being taught?
Get the new PD toolbar! President Obama last week deftly defused Gatesgate when he made a surprise appearance in the White House briefing room and noted that he regretted having said that the Cambridge police had acted "stupidly." He reported that he had spoken to Crowley and that in the course of their conversation the suggestion had arisen: a can-we-all-get-along beer at the White House. We reporters at the White House weren't sure at first if Obama was serious about that. But the lid was off the bottle, and all talk of the Crowley-Gates affair turned to the pending foamy reconciliation -- and, of course, the beer of choice for the three participants.
Mission Accomplished. Obama had gotten himself out of a hole of his own making.
But aside from demonstrating how to handle a PR challenge, is there any other edification that can come from this three-way chug-fest? Is this, say, a model for improving police-community relations? Not really. In most cities, the sadly inevitable conflicts between officers and residents will not be eased by subsequent White House-brokered sit-downs. (The president is a busy guy.)
At the White House press briefing on Tuesday, CBS News correspondent Chip Reid pressed Gibbs on what the Crowley-Gates meeting could yield in practical terms. The question may have been a bit unfair, for the White House is not quite billing this encounter as on par with the time President Jimmy Carter brought together Egypt's Anwar Sadat and Israel's Menachem Begin. But Reid wanted to know if the White House was "doing anything to . . . make this a continuing teachable moment." Gibbs said, "I don't have anything specific on that."
Part of the problem is that we don't know what caused the problem between the two men. Did tempers flare and lead to Gates' arrest because of racial factors? That's how the episode was cast in many quarters at first. Such an assumption was not far-fetched. Racial profiling has long been a problem throughout the nation, and law enforcement conflicts often have racial undertones -- or overtones. Given that Obama had worked against racial profiling as a legislator, it would be natural for him to want him to use a high-profile example to increase public awareness and push for remedies.
But so far there's no telling if race fueled the face-off in Cambridge. Might it have been class? In academic communities, there's often tension between town and gown. (See "Good Will Hunting.") And it's not hard to imagine some Cambridge cops bearing resentment toward Harvard faculty members for the, uh, obvious reasons. So is it class friction that has to be ameliorated through the judicious application of barley and hops?
A teachable moment generally requires clarity. For instance, Obama could have truly scored a T.M. at his press conference last week if, while discussing health care reform, he took out a list of all the campaign contributions insurance firms have made to Republican and Democratic legislators working on the health care bill and read it aloud to a national audience: "Wonder why it's tough to get health care reform through Congress? Well, study up on this, people." Now that would have been instructional.
The Crowley-Gates beer, though, is not likely to signal much more than that Obama can clean up a mess quickly. That's actually a good trait for a commander in chief to possess. It was refreshing to see a president acknowledge in a mature manner that he had screwed up. And even though Crowley is reportedly coming to Washington escorted by a police union official and an attorney, the script now calls for all three men to be gracious and to say encouraging words about mutual understanding. The message will be: Make toasts, not war. There's nothing wrong with that. But it's not that much of a lesson. When all's said and drunk, the educational agenda of the get-together seems rather light. Or make that lite.
******
Sharp-eyed readers might notice that the title of this blog is the same as that of a novel I wrote a few years ago. I'd like you all to know that I'm no relentless self-promoter. (Note the use of the word "relentless.") My editor suggested this title for the blog and, more important, nixed several others. So "Deep Background" it is. By the way, you can follow my postings and media appearances via Twitter.
David Corn is the Washington bureau chief for Mother Jones magazine. Prior to that he was the Washington editor of The Nation magazine for twenty years... more
No big dealio with the Beer Summit. I think it is a manufactured distraction.
Good piece!
Thanks for all you do
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
sandsnnydz
9:12AM Jul 30th 2009
it is a lesson in knee jerk reactions from Mr. Cool our President
a teachable moment? lessons learned ? at the peace picnic table?
joke....
RATE THIS COMMENT: (6)
obama yo mama
3:54PM Jul 30th 2009
Obowma's run-ins with the cambridge police while there in college is why he called them stupid. 17 unpaid tickets until just before he ran for president shows a total disregard for the police.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (4)
jrotced02
5:11PM Jul 30th 2009
I'm glad that you people are too blind to see what President Obama's real agenda is...think about this for moment...two of the most educated men and successful men in America, showing a common street cop that he is waaaaaaaay out of his league, on national television. and just what are they going to talk about? Economics? International relations? Community activism? Crowley will do his best not to look like an idiot, despite all of the coaching he's no doubt gotten. All Obama has to do, is be gracious, and the entire world will see Crowley, and all of his supporters, for what they really are. Remember this...outside of Cambridge, Crowley is just a nobody, while Gates is still a distinguished Harvard professor. and in the last 48 hours, a white Boston cop and a white staffer have lost their jobs for sending racist e-mails. Still think this is not about race? Stay tuned.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
kathy
5:17PM Jul 30th 2009
jrotced, you must be a person of color with a hard on against the world. And just because Gates has a college education dont think for a minute that he is more intelligent than the other fellow, they are two men who chose different paths in life.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (4)
trouser trout
6:50PM Jul 30th 2009
I think the president should never get involved with issues like this. Would FDR, RN, IKE, LBJ, JFK ever do this I think not. the President is a little young for the office.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (2)
ihmdsm85
10:01AM Aug 1st 2009
I see the Republicans in their parents basement are mouthing off again!:) Please do yourself a favor and get a job.=) President Barak Obama is killing the Bush/Republican policies that put America on a one way path into this recession. Remember Glass/Steagal! Phil Gram of Texas! ETC. President Barak Obama is alittle over six months in office and the economy is starting to recover! Congratulations!And remember 400,000-4.5% in taxes = Healthcare for all Americans! PRICELESS! Freedom!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
Angela
9:30AM Jul 30th 2009
Earth to David Cornball... come in Cornball....
It will at least be a grand photo-op? The "teachable moment" here is that taxpayers should ask themselves why we bitch about paying for pro-America photo ops, but will pay more than that for this useless puppet show. I mean, shouldn't we compain when 3 beers will cost us taxpayers as much, if not more than, the "other" publicity photos? Should we compare returns on our costs and compare the 2 situations?
Part of the problem is that we don't know what caused the problem between the two men? Well, we have the testimony from a 911 call, the police report, Gates' account of the incident, and the press account. Ultimately, they have all given the same account. This narrows down the number of those who don't know what happened to one ignorant person, who shall remain nameless.
But so far there's no telling if race fueled the face-off in Cambridge? Since when is the accusation of "racial profiling" unclear about whether race fueled an altercation?
The Crowley-Gates beer, though, is not likely to signal much more than that Obama can clean up a mess quickly? Quickly? The only thing people are interested in after this has dragged on for so long is what label beer they're going to drink!
Better luck next time, Cornball.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
moderate
2:31PM Jul 30th 2009
The accounts were not the same. Crowly wrote "black" men, 911 call did not mention this. Caller said two suitcases does not know what is going on, please check. Crowly... 2 black men, backpacks, breaking into a home.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (2)
capt
9:37AM Jul 30th 2009
Maybe Barack should have held the photo op under a "Mission Accomplished" banned on an aircraft carrier?
I'd wager that little BS photo op cost much more han a few beers?
your quoting the "haters" at the Daily Koz ......says it all
RATE THIS COMMENT: (2)
fyrefli144
12:30PM Jul 30th 2009
illogical liberal babbling need we say more get over, he's left and now we have the antichrist deal with
RATE THIS COMMENT: (2)
jrotced02
5:35PM Jul 30th 2009
moderate: You and I seem to be the only people who bothered to read all of the articles, and gleen what are apparently now facts. When was the last time you EVER heard about a man being arrested in his own, for 'lipping off" to a cop? It never happens...never! What is more likely to have happened, was that Crowley needed an excuse to put this man in his place, and probably baited/goaded gates into this situateion. You all seem to forget (and I've said it a thousand times)it is not against ANY law to mouth off to a cop. It may be foolish, unwise, or immature, but it breaks NO law. and second, aren't cops trained to expect verbal abuse, and taught how to defuse it? Crowley could have defuzed the situation be leaving as soon as he was satisfied Gates had identified himself. he CHOSE to remain, and ramp up the situation.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (2)
groundspeed
9:39AM Jul 30th 2009
You could be satisfied with a "no fault" outcome after the beer meeting. The problem is "blackitude" still persists. In the company of Whites, this arrogance is generally accomodated or ignored. In the company of their own, it's usually a shortcut to multiple gunshot wounds. If you've been immersed in their culture, you know this is a stark reality. One might ask: where does the proble ACTUALLY reside? It may be a "teaching moment" but I doubt it will be a learning moment in the Black community.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (6)
norfwest
11:52AM Jul 30th 2009
I take it that you have been "immersed" in black culture? That is to say, you have been in concert with Cornell West, Michael Eric Dyson as well as Curtis "50 Cent" Jackson and DMX? You have had coversations with Black CEO's as well as with the two-bit drug dealers and addicts? Black culture is much broader than the mere image of "thug life" that you take as the gospel.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-2)
sawgunna01
8:39PM Jul 30th 2009
hey groundspeed: man you are lost I guess your interpretation of blacks comes those dumb music videos and movies that misrepresent blacks anyway not all blacks are what you see on t.v. shootings drugs and gangs! would it be fair to say whites rape men, cut them up and eat them then put the rest in the freezer for later? (and that was actual life not a music video or movie remember jeff dahmer)? Many serial killers are white, is that the correct representation of whites? Or just a few bad apples in the bunch? Think realistically you silly human!!!!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (2)
builder46
9:44AM Jul 30th 2009
crowley should have taught gates to keep his black mouth shut.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (5)
Chris Williams
4:12PM Aug 4th 2009
Let's send a black cop to your house. Have him accuse you of breaking in. Show him your ID with your picture and address on it. Then have him say that this is not good enough proof. And when you protest that somebody has disrespcted you in your own house by calling you a liar and calling you outside, then we'll have him shut your mouth.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
capt
9:47AM Jul 30th 2009
Obama Accused of Continuing Bush's Racial Profiling of Immigrants
Maybe there is "teachable" moment here. Barack runs foul every time he follows what Bush did. He has to stop that stuff. He can't be more concerned with racial profiling without considering the profiling of Hispanics.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-2)
mayabelle1107
9:58AM Jul 30th 2009
Why did obama and the department of justice drop charges against 3 members of the new black panther party, that stood outside of a Philadelphia voting location, with night sticks calling white people honkeys and crackers and refusing them the right granted in the Constitution to vote? Just wondering.....