Politics Daily
Inside Politics Daily
Valentine's Dinner Odds in Blizzard Season
Scott Brown and the Palin Path: Will He Choose Brassy or Boring?
Democrats Leave Health Care Behind for Jobs, Toyota, Gays in Military
Murtha Turned Against War, but Not Grab-While-You-Can Politics
Rep. John Murtha, Advocate for Pa. District, Pentagon, Dies at 77
Liz Christman, Enemy of the Passive Voice, Who Rocked Some Jaunty Hats
Is Obama's Search for 'Common Ground' Real?- Tim Tebow's Brilliant Fake Leads to Pro-Life Score
'Snowmageddon' in D.C. -- The Politics, Talk Shows and Snowball Fights Go On
Sarah Palin Serves Tea Party Delegates Red Meat and Certainty
My Left Breast Put Fancy TSA Scanner to the Test
From a Grass Roots Tea Party, a PAC Blooms
A Bum Steer: Big Beef Throws Its Weight Around at Cal Poly
Big Beef has a bone to pick with Michael Pollan. And who can blame it? After all, Pollan, a professor of journalism at University of California at Berkeley and a critic of industrial agriculture, almost got away with delivering a lecture last week to students at California Polytechnic State University in San Luis Obispo. How dare he?!Pollan had been invited by the university's Sustainable Agriculture Resource Consortium, a faculty-run group that works to make sure students are exposed to alternatives to conventional agricultural practices.
Apparently Big Beef decided to get mad -- and get even. David E. Wood, chairman of the Harris Ranch Beef Co., a sprawling feedlot and meat-processing operation that produces 150 million pounds of beef per year, pitched a fit in a letter to the university's president, Warren Baker. Wood also happens to be an alumnus of the school -- and a generous donor (he pledged $150,000 toward a new meat-processing plant for the campus's herd, according to news reports).
In his letter, posted by New York University nutrition professor Marion Nestle on her blog, Food Politics, Wood threatened to reconsider his donation. He wrote, "While I understand the need to expose students to alternative views, I find it unacceptable that the university would provide Michael Pollan an unchallenged forum to promote his stand against conventional agricultural practices." He also railed against a professor who identified "grass-fed" and "organic" farming systems as sustainable, but not "grain-fed" production systems.
How did Cal Poly respond? Not quite the way a respected institution of higher learning that has the best interest of its students at heart would. The school caved -- though in a letter responding to Wood, Baker defended the school's efforts to involve students in the debate over sustainability. Still, the university changed the format from a lecture by Pollan to a panel discussion, adding a professor of meat science and the founder of a large organic vegetable company. (The event was held last Thursday.)
I agree that a panel is a fine and appropriate way to debate the complex issues involved with how our food is grown and raised. But was it necessary to stifle one lecture by one person to mollify an angry donor? It's not like Big Ag doesn't get to have its say on this subject. Aren't the agricultural and land-grant schools already heavily focused on teaching conventional farming practices? And isn't 90 percent of the beef in this country already industrially farmed and processed?
More importantly, what about academic freedom?
Believe it or not, I am all for hearing dissenting view points. Take this one, an articulate critique of Pollan's book by someone whose family has been farming in this country for generations. I don't buy all of his arguments, but I appreciate his perspective, especially as I am not a farmer but a consumer.
Big Beef may hope to silence critics like Michael Pollan. Me? I'm going to buy the just-released young reader's edition of Pollan's book "The Omnivore's Dilemma" for my kids. You know, in the interest of academic freedom.
PD toolbar!
and download the new Politics Daily toolbar!
-
PRINT
-
IM
-
E-mail
3 comments
+ add your own
Domenica Marchetti
Domenica Marchetti is the author of Big Night In: More Than 100 Wonderful Recipes for Feeding Family and Friends Italian-Style and The Glorious Soups and Stews of Italy... moreRelated Articles
Related Articles
- Duke University Clashes with Local Union
Campuses all over the nation constantly struggle to maintain good relations with their host cities. It's mutualistic: colleges and universities provide innovation, technology and bustling life, while...
- Medill Innocence Project Fights Subpoenas of Student Records
Professor David Protess and his students in the Medill School of Journalism use their journalistic skills to prove that convicted criminals are innocent, often winning their release from prison (at...
- Telangana State Controversy: Indian University Students Take Up the Fight
HYDERABAD, India -- In the middle of the University of Hyderabad's expansive campus is a large, haphazard tent, pitched precariously with sticks and rope. On a weekday afternoon, about 25 graduate...
Comments (3)
JudgeGarth
10:46AM Oct 21st 2009
I trust you also support academic freedom on issues such as political correctness and speech codes.
RATE THIS COMMENT:
(0)
(0) 
domenica
1:30PM Oct 21st 2009
Absolutely, JudgeGarth. As a former newspaper reporter I place great value the First Amendment.
RATE THIS COMMENT:
(2)
(2) Bas
1:26PM Oct 21st 2009
Just another example of those with the most money getting their way. We already have extortion in politics - why not move it into the academic arena?
We're already gearing up to allow our chicken to come in from China (thanks, Tyson lobbyists). After all, the imported pet food, childrens toys, etc., were so problem-free...
We're already gearing up to allow our chicken to come in from China (thanks, Tyson lobbyists). After all, the imported pet food, childrens toys, etc., were so problem-free...
RATE THIS COMMENT:
(4)
(4) 
Woman Up on Facebook
Now Commenting
- Dave on:
Robert Gibbs Gets Hands-On About Mocking Sarah Palin - john black on:
Voters, Especially Independents, Sour on Obama and Congress - Dave on:
Robert Gibbs Gets Hands-On About Mocking Sarah Palin - Crandall on:
Robert Gibbs Gets Hands-On About Mocking Sarah Palin - Lone Star on:
Robert Gibbs Gets Hands-On About Mocking Sarah Palin - Beamer on:
Robert Gibbs Gets Hands-On About Mocking Sarah Palin
Submit Your Favorite Links
No.
Props
Props
- 34
- 35
- 29
- 31
- 26
- 21
Follow Politics Daily
Other News
- Get busy, Democrats
- Behind Liz Cheney's group, a weird legacy of torture
- The race is on for Murtha's seat
- The real political realities
- Senate blocks NLRB appointee
- Gay Soldier Invited Back to Guard Unit
- Schumer's Wall Street Donors Look for Revenge
- Michael Steele Suggests Racism Fuels His Critics
- Robert Gibbs Pokes Fun at Sarah Palin
- World Likes Obama Much More Than Bush
- Ellen's First Night
- The Perfect Homemade Candies
- The Mystery of Yo-Yo Ma's Name
- White Out
- How Palin Could Win
- Obama: I'll Meet GOP Halfway
- Unions Give $$$ to Target Tea Partiers
- Second Blast of Winter Slams D.C.
- Clinton Hostage-Taker Now a Fugitive
- Toyota Recalls 437,000 Prius, Hybrids Globally
Politics Daily More Links