Download the Politics Daily Toolbar
Our new toolbar integrates the latest news and analysis into your Web browser and installs in seconds. Download it now!

Politics DailyPolitics Daily

  • HOME
  • ABOUT
  • COLUMNISTS
  • TOPICS
  • THE CAPITOLIST
  • WOMAN UP
  • DAILY FLOTUS
  • JUST IN
  • THE CRAM
  • CONTACT
  • Inside Politics Daily

    The Ten Top (or Bottom) Moments of the Health Care Debate

    Posted:
    11/8/09
    I didn't really set out to watch the whole darn "debate" preceding yesterday's health care vote in the House, on one of the most beautiful days of the fall. But somehow, folding laundry with one eye on C-SPAN turned into a marathon of Notre Dame-Navy game-avoiding and "OMG, I thought he was dead"-muttering as some of the more senior (and rarely seen) members of Congress stepped to the mic. As a result, I can now state with authority that a shocking number of our elected representatives do not have anyone who is giving it to them straight – at least insofar as their toupees are concerned.
    Here are my personal fave moments of the day, in no particular order:
    Get the new
    PD toolbar!
    1) Easy for you to say: At one point, Republican Leader John Boehner of Ohio was going on and on about how, if health care reform were enacted, President Obama's "health choices czar" would personally swoop in to decide just about everything for us, stripping us of the personal freedom not to set a broken bone or have our teeth cleaned. "My colleagues might think this is hyper-bull," he said, either mispronouncing hyperbole or letting his Freudian slip. Yes, they just might.
    2) Minnesota's red-hot (and it must be said, quite beautiful) Michele Bachmann, wearing a lei given to her by a couple who had come all the way from Hawaii to stand with those comparing health care reform to the Holocaust, again had me wondering why she's not her party's Sarah Palin. She's every bit as conservative, yet far more experienced. ("The American people overwhelmingly reject the government takeover of our health care,'' Bachmann said. "Last Friday a couple from Hawaii decided the time was so short they needed to get on a plane, come to Washington, to beg their representative to vote no - from Hawaii. What sacrifices freedom-loving Americans are making to get their government's attention...They brought me this beautiful, precious lei and I'm reminded that the one who created this lei also created our freedom.")
    3) I also wondered, and not for the first time, do Republicans not get sick? I'm not sure I know anyone who's had a serious illness and still loves his insurer. The Rs keep talking about how this horror of a health care bill will put bureaucrats between patients and their doctors – when I can't remember a time when bureaucrats weren't between me and my doctor. Finally, Michigan Democrat John Dingell made the counter-argument that what this bill actually aims to do is get between us and the (insurance company) bureaucrats who are already there.
    4) Texas Rep. Charlie Gonzalez made a good point, too, I thought, even if nobody much was listening, when he said that tort reform in his state hadn't worked any of the miracles its proponents routinely promise; health insurance is more expensive than ever, he said, and docs in rural areas just as scarce. His fellow Texas Democrat Chet Edwards, on the other hand, put out one of the more disingenuous statements of the day by way of explaining his no vote on the bill: "Throughout this debate I have heard two extremes. Some on the far left would like to see the federal government run a socialized health care system. Some on the far right would get the government completely out of health care, which would mean the elimination of Medicare and Medicaid." Except that this legislation wouldn't do anything of the kind in terms of socializing medicine, and no Republican spoke of eliminating government-supported health care for the poor or the elderly. (Some of these moderates can be so extreme!)
    5) As for the Stupak Amendment super-duper pinky-swearing to lock and then deadbolt the door against the possibility of any federal $$ paying for abortions: Republicans keep saying, as Boehner did yesterday, that "the underlying bill allows for funding of abortion,'" though it never did any such thing. The Stupak language was superfluous, but politically necessary to address the concern that federal money can prove to be fungible – and could thus leach into "family planning" programs. Although I share Stupak's abortion views, I must admit his amendment does go well beyond the Hyde Amendment, and probably will limit access to abortion, which is why several of the pro-choice Democratic women who spoke on the subject last night looked like they could happily serve the gentleman from Michigan a nice, juicy Henry Allen-style knuckle sandwich. In her pique, Diana DeGette of Colorado went so far as to compare an unplanned pregnancy to cancer.
    6) Speaking to reporters yesterday, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's voice cracked while she was talking about the late Ted Kennedy. (And thinking, perhaps, of Bart Stupak?) She was reportedly furious that pro-life Dems had exacted such a price for their support – but would she rather have gone home empty-handed? Not a close call.
    7) InstaClassic: A lot of these pols like pretending so much that it was either Congress or acting school, and they clearly made the right decision. Boehner again made my day when he (mock innocently) asked Charlie Rangel to guarantee that the Stupak language would be in the final bill. Rangel answered that, duh, he had no idea what would happen in the House-Senate conference committee, where differences between the two versions of the bill will be ironed out: "You've been here long enough to truly understand how this system works. As soon as we pass this bill, then we would expect the Democratic-controlled Senate to pass their bill, and then we will go into conference'' -- and meet in the middle. With a perfect poker face, Rangel continued, "And I would think any member that gives a guarantee might be in violation of our ethics laws.'' Hmm, like the ones Rangel's already being investigated for allegedly breaking? Yes, those. Shifting gears, Boehner then asked the strongly pro-choice New York Democrat if he himself planned to support the Stupak amendment. "Do I have your guarantee?'' Boehner asked, pointing his finger at Rangel – and then interrupting as soon as Rangel actually started to answer him, provoking the New Yorker to shout, "Why are you so rude? You asked me a question! Shame on you!'' Good to see public servants so enjoying their work.
    8) Civil rights hero John Lewis, a Georgia Democrat, gave the hands-down rockin'-est speech of the day: "If we fail to act on health care,'' he thundered, "history will not be kind to any of us."
    9) And Democrat Rep. Phil Hare, from my home state of Illinois, quietly and movingly talked about how when he was a kid, his folks had lost their home because of monster medical bills they couldn't pay. They'd come home from his sister's wedding and found an eviction notice waiting for them, he said – and added that on his father's deathbed, his dad had asked two things of him: That he look after his mom and sis, and that he do something to make sure what happened to their family wouldn't happen to others. Yesterday, Hare said, he felt he was making good on that promise.
    10) The final vote was a little bit of a nail-nibbler despite confident reports from Democrats throughout the day, and when the time for voting ran out, supporters of the bill counted it down on the House floor – "Ten, nine, eight...'' – as it it were New Year's Eve. But for all of our pro-forma kvetching about the stomach-turning sight of the sausage being made, those of us mesmerized by democracy should just admit it: Really, it had been Christmas all day.



    Follow PoliticsDaily On Facebook and Twitter,
    and download the new Politics Daily toolbar!

    Melinda Henneberger

    Melinda Henneberger is the editor-in-chief of PoliticsDaily.com. She spent 10 years as a reporter for the New York Times, in the paper’s Washington and Rome bureaus... more

    Contact Melinda Henneberger

    subscribe to: RSS email: Melinda Henneberger

    Related Articles

    Related Articles

    • Happening Right Now

       
    Politics Daily on Facebook

    Other News