Two viral videos of girl-on-girl and woman-on-woman violence grabbed the world by the throat this week and raised the question: Are American females becoming more violent?
In the first video, punch-throwing, hair-pulling, brawling high school soccer players were caught on tape by a Rhode Island TV station just before the match between their Woonsocket and Tolman high school teams was about to end.
Then, last Friday, the University of New Mexico suspended soccer player Elizabeth Lambert for a variety of violent moves, including pulling an opponent's pony tail so hard she jerked the young player to the ground and appeared to have wrenched her neck. Click play below to watch the video:
What's going on here? The first part of the answer is that violence in women's sports is nothing new. In soccer, for example, there's a lot of jostling, pushing and shoving, even among some of the youngest players. Lambert may have taken female violence in this sport to a new high, or to a recent high, but she certainly is not the first to perpetuate such foul and unexpected behavior. And she may not be unusual at all -- just unfortunate to have been caught on video camera.
The second part of the answer is that female-on-female violence outside of sports is nothing new, either.
To determine if female violence is really on the rise, we need to step back and look at a few statistics. There are many categories of female-perpetrated violence, but it's safe to say when women and girls become violent, it's more often against someone of their own size or smaller. The most horrific category of child-killing, neonaticide (killing of a child within 24 hours of birth) is committed almost exclusively by women. It's a rare occurrence, but one worth noting.
The Justice Department's National Criminal Justice Reference Services reports that "Neonaticide offenders are typically young, unmarried women who lack resources. However, further examination of the data revealed that women in their 30s and 40s also committed this type of crime as well as women who were married. The majority of offenders fell within middle to upper socioeconomic status and had resources available that they did not use (transportation, health care, abortion costs.)"
The surprise in this data, at least to me, is that neonaticide is most often committed by middle- and upper-income women. The woman-on-woman violence I've seen in my life always seemed to involve women in the poorer parts of town. I saw girl fights outside public high schools and in alleyways in Manhattan. I even had a punch pulled on me in a barn when I was in my 30s. But the fights I witnessed as a teen were all between lower-income girls. And the young woman who pulled her fist back threatening to punch me came from a lower-income family. I saw it as a culture clash personified.
An Amazon.com review of Patricia Pearson's 1998 book, "When She Was Bad," cites the following data about other forms of female-perpetrated violent crimes: "Women commit the majority of child homicides in the United States; more than 80 percent of neonaticides; an equal or greater share of severe physical child abuse; an equal rate of spousal assault; about a quarter of child sexual molestations; and a large proportion of elder abuse . . . The rate at which infants are murdered by women . . . is higher than the rate at which women are murdered by men." With carefully researched facts, fascinating case histories, and incisive argument, Patricia Pearson succeeds in demolishing the myth that women are not naturally violent.
Even though Pearson's data are more than a decade old, she makes a good point. Are we naturally violent? The answer to that is yes -- a certain percentage of us are more violent than society is comfortable believing. Remember, just as many girls witness violence in the home as boys. So how could we expect girls to grow up any less violent than their brothers? And yet the fact overall is, women are not as violent as men. Testosterone does make a difference.
Is it time to stop seeing men as the primary perpetrators of domestic violence? Although we're becoming more accustomed to female violence, we're not at the point where we can say domestic violence is gender-neutral. Police data show if and when women become violent in the home, it's more often to defend themselves than to initiate the violence. Not that men are the violent beasts early feminists such as Andrea Dworkin believed them to be. The movement has learned some valuable lessons from its early overreactions. But men still initiate the vast majority of domestic violence against women.
If women and girls are getting more violent, it's because society is becoming more violent and there's more violence in the media than ever before. A report released late last month on violence against women on mainstream U.S. television shows it has increased by 120 percent in the past five years, with the depiction of teen girls as victims rising by some 400 percent.
If we're seeing more violence in the media against women, how can we be surprised when young women start to parrot that behavior?
Bonnie Erbé is host and Executive-In-Charge of the PBS program, To the Contrary. This award-winning news analysis program airs nationally on 260 PBS stations each week... more
The excitement of " Snowmageddon " may have overshadowed another important event that occurred at the end of last week.
In a rare showing of bipartisanship, politicians introduced the International...
This weekend, veteran CNN reporter Candy Crowley takes on a high-profile role in the often rough-and-tumble world of Sunday morning talk shows. As the new host of CNN's "State of the Union," Crowley...
Have modern marriage, women's income and education levels intersected in such a way as to foment " The Rise of the Sugar Mama ?"
Some signs certainly point that way, including a new Pew Foundation...
They need to start 'whooping some as-', the GOP just uses them for 'cheer leaders'. What ever happened to women like Margret Thatcher?
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
kathy
5:42AM Nov 13th 2009
Margaret Thatcher? The best man England ever had.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
moderate
1:26PM Nov 13th 2009
Your comment is part of the problem kathy.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-4)
kathy
5:46AM Nov 13th 2009
After watching the video, I'd say Elizabeth Lambert has a violent streak. She isn't just playing soccer, she sets out to hit, trip and tug, all around little b___ch. And the referees should have called her on it. Whats wrong with the Refs!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (17)
my stuff
10:06AM Nov 13th 2009
She needs to join boxing if she is tough enough. everything she did was cheap, and a surprise attack. The refres need to be fired since they cannot manage the players.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (7)
Sugar
12:11PM Nov 13th 2009
This person show's unsportsmanship, and should never ever be allowed to play again, she will indeed cause a riot so day, or seriously hurt or even kill some one, anger is in her soul.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (5)
theburning3rd
1:16PM Nov 13th 2009
I saw it...this is just another example of what happens when lazy people sit back and allow anything to happen. Back in the day, only 20 years ago, a girl like this would be coerced to quit the team and her parents would be called into a meeting. People stop hair pulling at age 10. This is serious lack of discipline in both the households and society.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (5)
mupthegrov
12:34PM Nov 14th 2009
If you watch more carefully, before Lambert punched that girl in the back, the girl elbowed her in the solar plexus; and, before she pulled the other girl's hair, the girl was grabbing her shorts pulling upwards and outwards. While Lambert does seem to give out more than she takes, she was not the initiator of either of these incidents.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (1)
Painter0fwords
5:55AM Nov 13th 2009
LOL Have you ever visited an aol lesbian chatroom? I think a few of them are even mentioned in the beatitudes :-X Come in and say hello
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-3)
sequin22
7:20AM Nov 13th 2009
This author and the feminist she quotes are a pair of politically correct ostriches with their heads in the sand. Womens violence has risen along with the "gender role changes"- if you cant see that, you are deliberately trying not to.
Further more, violent women who beat on their husbands and children are not necessarily "defending themselves." Some of the worst child abuse cases on record were committed by a woman. Let's pull our heads out of the sand.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (14)
sequin22
7:24AM Nov 13th 2009
As we teach our young daughters to competitive, assertive and demanding (male behavioral patterns)- they will indeed act more like men. The "gender bender " mentality has been no friend to femininity.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (4)
garry402
8:06AM Nov 13th 2009
Oh yeah, full contact soccer. Way to woman-up Elizabeth Lambert.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-3)
Irish67
8:20AM Nov 13th 2009
What do we, as a society, expect? We've defeminized women and emasculated men. We raise our girls to be assertive and ignore traditional gender roles, and if anyone tells them to 'behave' then it's called sexist. We deserve what we get. Feminism and trade unions have a lot in common; they had their time and served a purpose, now they've gone too far and destroyed social order and capitalism.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (2)
moderate
1:23PM Nov 13th 2009
Please enlighten this assertive, educated, long married, and highly successful woman what "traditianal females roles are" Could that be when a woman was owned by her father then her husband. Or when the rule of thumb was legal( beat a woman with a stick no wider then a mans thumb) or how about when we were not allowed to vote or work. Please be specific.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-7)
Cutie
8:36AM Nov 13th 2009
The same problem that affects young women has also affected young men. Women who have to work for a living or suppliment the household funds are no longer home to take care and guide children. There isn't the bonding there use to be and kids no longer care about anyone but themselves. The me first generation has raised a me kid generation. We need to go back and beef up jobs in this country, cut taxes, raise duties on foreign goods, and give the families a chance to recover.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (3)
gvpal52
9:53AM Nov 13th 2009
Holly Wood + desperation = violent
RATE THIS COMMENT: (1)
Elizabeth
9:54AM Nov 13th 2009
Aggression is learned behavior or genetic, so it wouldn't surprise me or women are becoming more equal to their male peers. Long ago, women were very dependent on their male partners and did not have to worry about survival. Could be a lot of different things.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-3)
pxamerican3
9:59AM Nov 13th 2009
Hmm, after reading this article, I began to wonder if there are more Ms. Bobbits out there. That's a real concern, right?
RATE THIS COMMENT: (0)
ssgoodluck
10:14AM Nov 13th 2009
Just wait until more women start having to pay child support to men, heaven forbid! Wacko Anna Heche is just the tip of the iceberg. Don't believe it? Ask any man that tries to renegotiate child support payments after a job loss, hours or benefits reduction. Women fight over money more vehemently than love. After all half of us know it already. . . . . . . .
RATE THIS COMMENT: (5)
doug
10:28AM Nov 13th 2009
Ha! I was with a woman who had a volatile temper that eventually became violent. Before it did, I warned her I would leave should she become violent. I guess she didn't believe me, because when she did, I left that instant - not the next day or week. I'm a foot taller and weigh 100 lbs more, so she didn't get the richly deserved punch. Had I done so, no doubt she would have called the cops who would then have arrested me. Guys, if you are with one of these crazy women, get out now while you have the chance, your sanity - and a clean record!