The produce used on the Food Network's Jan. 3 Iron Chef of America two-hour special White House show was billed as being from the White House garden. But the show did not disclose that "stunt double vegetables" were used and not produce from the First Family's garden.
The much ballyhooed show featured a cameo by First Lady Michelle Obama who invited the chefs to pick what they needed from the White House garden in the opening scenes. Mrs. Obama agreed to appear --and give the show access to the garden -- because the episode promoted her healthy eating themes and the garden, her signature first-year project. Iron Chef also reaches an audience that would be interested in Mrs. Obama's local food, anti-obesity and exercise agenda.
The cook-off featured White House executive chef Cristeta Comerford and star chefs Bobby Flay, Mario Batali and Emeril Lagasse. At the top of the show the chefs were greeted by Mrs. Obama who invites them to harvest what they needed from the White House garden in order to complete their challenge of preparing five "ultimate American" dishes using fresh and local ingredients. Comerford, teamed with Flay won the competition. Click play below to watch a segment from the start of the show (Michelle Obama's entrance at 1:30).
"Because this competition was about fresh fruits and vegetables, but also about the American experience, Chef Flay and I decided to cook to our strengths and to our heritages. To highlight the diversity of culinary traditions and flavors that define our country, Chef Flay cooked with his southwestern flair, I brought in recipes from my native Philippines, and we blended it all with unique takes on classic American recipes."
The White House segment was taped in late October. The cook-off actually took place the following week, in what Iron Chef calls its "Kitchen Stadium" in New York City.
So clearly the stuff that was picked that October day at the White House never had a chance of making it on the show because the produce would not be fresh. The use of the "stunt vegetables" was revealed in a November New York Times Marian Burros article and in Obamafoodorama.com, Eddie Gehman Kohan's web site-of-record on anything having to do with food and food policy coming out of the Obama White House. But no one knew until the show if the "stunt double" vegetables would be disclosed.
Viewers were not explicitly told that the vegetables in "Kitchen Stadium" were not the ones they had seen the chefs harvest. Various participants in the show misled viewers with references to "using radishes from the White House garden" and other similar mentions. Except for the honey, no food on the show came from the White House.
Mrs. Obama's East Wing told me the vegetables picked at the White House garden that day in October were donated to a local food kitchen, so nothing went to waste. The week between the harvest the cook-off was due to "scheduling/technical" reasons.
Lisa Krueger, the public relations director for the Food Network, sent an e-mail to me after I raised questions about why viewers were misled.
"As we have told reporters who have covered this story from the beginning, due to the production delay between the shoot at the White House and the shoot at Food Network, the produce used in Kitchen Stadium during the "Super Chef Battle" was not actually from the White House garden." The actual vegetables used, Krueger said, were "locally sourced, and the chefs were only allowed to use the types of produce that they had harvested from the garden themselves."
Obamafoodarama reported that the ratings for the White House Iron Chef of America special "set new viewer records for Food Network. ....With about 4.6 million viewers, it was the highest rated and most-watched show in Food Network's history."
Lynn Sweet is a columnist at PoliticsDaily.com and writes the Daily FLOTUS blog on Michelle Obama. She is also Washington Bureau Chief of the Chicago Sun-Times.... more
bonbon - get some help. You obviously need it. Mrs. Obama does not control The Food Network you moron.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-2)
oilriggas
2:56PM Jan 12th 2010
Like everything else in this White House, smoke and mirrors. What more would you expect?
RATE THIS COMMENT: (253)
Stella
5:37PM Jan 12th 2010
Well SURPRISE-SURPRISE-SURPRISE!!!! The White House lied to us. Where's the news here?
RATE THIS COMMENT: (230)
Simzee
8:35PM Jan 12th 2010
Don't forget the liquid courage to make it all happen.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-81)
Mary
8:38PM Jan 12th 2010
SO WHAT'S NEW ALL LIES ALWAYS LIES!!!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (163)
Colleen
10:13PM Jan 12th 2010
much ado about nothing. i mean seriously. this is tv after all. they did their best to stay true to the intent. get over it.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (66)
RBJ
10:55PM Jan 12th 2010
What a surprise.This woman is supposed to be awe inspiring and the best she can do is fake a garden.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (65)
paulio629
12:01AM Jan 13th 2010
you mean tv AND the white house lie? my reality is forever altered....or not.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (128)
njvalkyrie
9:09AM Jan 13th 2010
Actually, it was Food Network who lied, not the White House. Get a grip.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (5)
Carole
2:06PM Jan 14th 2010
you've got THAT right. Smoke and mirrors - just the way Obama planned it
RATE THIS COMMENT: (39)
smuckinfarter
2:36PM Jan 14th 2010
Me thinks the white house had less to do with this than that of the food network! Geez are you people just anti everything??
RATE THIS COMMENT: (54)
ladybugost
2:58PM Jan 14th 2010
I can't believe that any of you really think that this is all about the Obamas lying!!!! The food network misrepresented the show. If they couldn't use the vegetables fresh that day, then they should never have announced that it was a show about fresh vegetables from the White House garden. Get over the fact that the Obamas are doing this country a world of good. Trying to fix the ROYAL MESS that the Bush's left us in will be nothing short of a miracle.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (5)
kathyrn5k
3:01PM Jan 14th 2010
They even lie about innocent vegetables!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (25)
tomflushing3
3:10PM Jan 14th 2010
Enough on the obombas already-you think that were the second coming of christ.Lets stop with the obessing with them.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (45)
paulinefoote
3:14PM Jan 14th 2010
On Point !!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (25)
Lisa
3:33PM Jan 14th 2010
Same old bull, different forum!!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (43)
cheryl
3:38PM Jan 14th 2010
I wonder if anyone else remembers that when this garden was planted, the whitehouse found out that there was a high number of toxins in the soil, and it was stated that because of this, they would not be able to partake in eating these veggies because of the toxins. Interesting that they should send the food to poison the "dregs of humanity" that partake of food at local food pantries. Sounds like genocide!!! ROFLMAO!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-20)
salamiboy1
4:15PM Jan 14th 2010
Food Network did the deceiving you moron.
RATE THIS COMMENT: (21)
Hugh Howard
4:26PM Jan 14th 2010
This comments says it all!
RATE THIS COMMENT: (-9)
bystephani
4:26PM Jan 14th 2010
Quit complaining you morons and Lynn Sweet, find something relevant to write about. TV production is obviously not something you know any thing about, so don't write about it any more. You write as if you are uncovering some big hidden secret. You did not. This has been going on for years. Do you not remember the countless times where during a cooking demonstration, they pop the dish in the oven and viola, like magic, there is a fully cooked dish waiting to be pulled out??? That is cooking in TV land! Get it LYNN?? There is no cover up going on here, you will not get a Pulitzer for this sleuthing, it was not a cover up job. The rest of you GROW UP.