Hot on HuffPost:

See More Stories

Afghanistan Journal: War at the End of the Road

1 year ago
  0 Comments Say Something  »
Text Size
David Wood
Chief Military Correspondent
Plumes of dust hung in the air as our convoy of armored vehicles crawled along the broad valley floor. As we approached the watchtowers and steel gates of Fort Gormach, a firefight with the Taliban broke out high on the steep hills along our left flank. A day later, we held up our departure while American F-16s dived on Taliban positions, which had taken U.S. and Afghan forces under fire. Perched on the fort's high walls, Afghan soldiers cheered wildly as three clouds of dark smoke rose where the 500-pound bombs had struck.

The U.S. Army's Forward Operating Base (FOB) Gormach is named after the nearby town in far northwest Afghanistan. This FOB is instantly recognizable as the modern version of the Old West stockades from which the Army campaigned against small bands of Indians, who raided and terrified cattlemen, sheep herders and dusty farm settlements, much as the Taliban do here today, often on horseback. The Indian wars, in their final phase, went on for 30 years.

Chow has improved since then (breakfast: two pieces of bacon, one sausage patty, one piece of bread, a cup of grape juice, and canned peaches, measured out by Staff Sgt. Malcolm Mullen of Hope Mills, North Carolina). But climb up to one of the steel watchtowers -- clamber up a 20-foot mound of dirt, balance along a 12-foot plank, then up steel steps -- and the Indian wars fort comes into view: A large rectangle of fortified walls anchored by the corner towers, enclosing an acre of heavy gravel. Rows of tan tents, a cook shack from which Mullen produces two hots a day, a line of steel shipping containers for storage, a concrete pad and awning for the mechanics, a four-seat plywood latrine baking in the sun, a parked fleet of armored vehicles, and several bunkers of steel and massive 8x8 timber to protect against incoming rockets and mortars.

A generator injects air conditioning into the tactical operations center (TOC) tent but nowhere else; in heat that commonly reaches 120 degrees (one time, 140, a soldier boasts), troops swelter on cots in dust-blown tents. There is no running water, little shade and only a rudimentary weight room for diversion. There's a refrigerated trailer for food storage, but it's busted. Mullen keeps everything, even canned stew, in a freezer (defrosting, in this heat, is no problem).

Beyond the FOB walls, this is the scene: Biblical hamlets of flat-roofed adobe dwellings and walled barnyards of goats and chickens; men and women bent at the waist scything and hand-threshing wheat; caravans of donkeys staggering under loads of grain and hay. In the distant hills, half-dissolved in the haze, are villages that can be reached only on foot or horseback, and gun-smugglers, fields of opium poppy, and Taliban, who until the U.S. Army arrived in April, enjoyed safe haven here.

From this modest home, war is waged against them by Headquarters Battery, 3rd Battalion 6th Field Artillery, 1st Brigade Combat Team, 10th Mountain Division, Capt. Stefan Hutnik of Marietta, Georgia, commanding. Hutnik takes me into one of the bunkers to talk; outside the crowded TOC it's the coolest place on the FOB.

This is a great job for a 32-year-old Army officer, Hutnik says. He's on his third tour in Afghanistan and this time he feels progress. He operates closely with the next-door Afghan army battalion, planning and executing joint operations. He sends out multiday patrols. He works with local politicians and elders to slowly shift the momentum here from Taliban-dominated to Taliban-unfriendly.

But it's hard living, and troops rotate here for six days at a time from Meimaneh, three hours away, where the U.S. FOB boasts hot water, air conditioned tents, and washer-dryers.

Out here, says 26-year-old Sgt. Brandon Beard, whose upbringing in Arkadelphia, Arkansas, didn't prepare him for the heat, "You try and get in the shade, you lose a lot of weight and you wait for wintertime,'' he said. Beard plans to move to Alaska.

Gormach is literally the end of the road. The internationally financed construction of Afghanistan's Ring Road, which nearly circumnavigates the country, stops just east of Gormach. The Ring Road, despite Taliban opposition, has heralded improved security, which in turn has encouraged the blossoming of markets and commerce and some government services. South Koreans built a magnificent stretch of Ring Road approaching Gormach from the east; the two-lane macadam with bright white lane markers cuts through ridgelines and soars across dry river beds. But Chinese workers, who took over from the Koreans, were regularly kidnapped by the Taliban outside Gormach. Eventually they fled and the pavement devolves into a crude dirt track.

You think this is bad? a soldier demands. "We had a patrol base set up a few miles from here, we had only two George Foreman grills and some meat. We'd go into the village and pay $5 for a garbage bag full of bread, sometimes vegetables. No one ever got sick from it. You gotta come down off your pedestal sometimes. The people out there in the villages have a deep-seated desire to know if there is a human being inside all our armor.''

Up in the watchtower, Pfc. Mason Daniels is a man with a mission. A generator mechanic on guard duty, he crouches behind an M240 machine gun that swivels on a tripod set on sand bags. He straightens up and scans the horizon with binoculars. "Nothin','' he announces with disgust. Daniels is thin with sandy hair and freckles and backwoods West Virginia in his voice.

When Daniels was 10, his uncle, Army Sgt. 1st Class Donald Bowles, was serving as a sniper with U.S. Marines in southern Afghanistan where he was killed by a Taliban rocket-propelled grenade. Nine years later, Daniels is back for revenge." Why I joined the Ahmee,'' he explains.

Daniels is itching to put some 7.62mm slugs from the machine gun into a Taliban. "I want them to be killed," he says. "Not give up, because they can come back. Killed!''

Angrily, he checks below and freezes. Here comes a donkey laboring under the weight of two men. One of them, Daniels asserts, is carrying a weapon. He snatches the radio, calls his sergeant, reports the possible Taliban almost under his nose. "I hope Sarn't says 'Engage,' '' Daniels tells me. "It's a bad day for these guys, because I ain't had much sleep and not in a good mood.''

The two men and donkey disappear behind the outer walls of Fort Gormach. Hidden from view, they could proceed unseen along any of a network of dry streambeds -- whether they are sneaky Taliban or local farmers.

Sarn't does not say "Engage,'' but Daniels is not convinced. Up go his binoculars. He whacks the sandbags. "C'mon!'' Minutes pass with no sign of men or donkey.

Hutnik's patrols are out somewhere in the hills, climbing in full combat gear. Inside a stifling tent, three Afghan soldiers stand and nod as an American sergeant explains through an interpreter how to use a sand table to rehearse tactics. In Gormach town, Hutnik's staff officers, unzipped from their sweaty body armor, sip tea with the elders, seeking agreement on possible development projects, the currency of counterinsurgency.

The sun seems immobile in the sky. It hammers on the steel roofs of Fort Gormach's watchtowers. Heat dances and shimmers above its gravel. Off-duty soldiers play listlessly at cards under a camouflage net. A soldier staggers out of the baked plywood privy, but little else moves. Daniels sourly scans the horizon. As in the Old West, the war grinds on.

Our New Approach to Comments

In an effort to encourage the same level of civil dialogue among Politics Daily’s readers that we expect of our writers – a “civilogue,” to use the term coined by PD’s Jeffrey Weiss – we are requiring commenters to use their AOL or AIM screen names to submit a comment, and we are reading all comments before publishing them. Personal attacks (on writers, other readers, Nancy Pelosi, George W. Bush, or anyone at all) and comments that are not productive additions to the conversation will not be published, period, to make room for a discussion among those with ideas to kick around. Please read our Help and Feedback section for more info.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum Comment Moderation Enabled. Your comment will appear after it is cleared by an editor.

14 Comments

Filter by:
Juan

Let us end this tragic war in Afghanistan.

August 01 2010 at 10:07 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
AHUMMER1USA

I really don't know what to say but thank you to all of those brave men and women over in Iraq and Afghanistan for their service to our country. It's brave folks like these that ensure our freedoms we citizens often time take for granite. I hope that after all of their suffering is over there in those foreign lands and is over said and done with that their sacrifices will not have gone in vain. I hope that those two countries realize what the US and the troops from around the world has done to help their countries get away from under thr rule of tyrants and terrorists. I also hope that America realizes what these soldiers have done as far as keeping the terrorists (the war) over there and away from our homeland as best as they could. It is also my sincerest hopes that America will take better care of her veterans and will have learned to have some respect for these soldiers if they didn't have already. I salute all the soldiers in harms way and may God Bless Them All and Their Families! And Also May God Bless America!

August 01 2010 at 9:25 PM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to AHUMMER1USA's comment
kingnus

Just amazing that some people still believe that Iraq and afghanistan were some how going to invade the USA and take away our FREEDOMS.

August 02 2010 at 4:24 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
dxman7

Mario1:57 PM Aug 1, 2010(2) vote this comment up (1) vote this comment down Sgt Bowles, you are in Afghanistan for the wrong reason. With that attitude of KILL, you should be rotated out and sent home! I am not impressed with Daniels either. This so-called war is 9 years too long! Mission is not going to be accomplished! Worst yet, many of these soldiers are coming home with alot of PTS. The Taliban are not going away! They will be back and will continue to fight until they resume control. What will we have gained? Alot of deaths on both sides!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
You are right, Mario (cabronzito). Britishes were defeated in the 19th century, Russians in the 20th century - but the lesson wasn't good enough. Surely if talibans get weak the Afghan military will jump to their side to fortify them.

August 01 2010 at 4:12 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
mick1840

its not our troops that are weak it our government they do not know how to win a war. we are to afraid of killing civilians, but they donot mind killing our troops. to win a war you have to kick ass, we have a president that has never been in the military that is how smart the american people are. he has no knowledge at all, yet he is the commander in chief what a joke. when you have a weak government you cant win a war, look at vietnam.

August 01 2010 at 3:50 PM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply
royalbrowniii

I rarely agree with liberal political positions but now believe the war in
Afghanistan is unwinnable and that we should exit soon. Our reason for going to war in Afghanistan was rational and just – to kill mostly non-Afghan Al Qaeda and their leaders who planned and carried out the 9/11 attack on the US and to dismantle their ability to mount future attacks.
This initial mission of Counter Terrorism was largely accomplished and can continue as needed with the use of armed drones launched from the US, special operations staged from Pakistan and a supporting intelligence network. However, the current policy of Counter Insurgency is mired in difficulties. There are just too many similarities with Viet Nam for this policy to succeed as follows:
• A corrupt government with no chance of substantially changing the system.
• A population that wants to be left alone to continue their century’s old, mostly rural existence.
• Primitive infrastructure (although VN was more modern) that will cost many more billions to be brought into the 21st Century.
• An Afghan army and national police whose loyalty and will to fight is questionable and is highly infiltrated with enemy sympathizers.
• A determined, native enemy in the Taliban.
• Ever increasing US and allied casualties.
• Sagging will of the American people to continue the war.
• A war that depends more on political solutions than military actions.
• A State Department dominated with anti-war and anti-military liberals.
Overlay on top of these similarities the fact that we are considered occupiers hated as infidels by devout Islamists including the Taliban, the same group that defeated the powerful Soviet Union. The situation worsens when you add the ridiculously strict Rules of Engagement hampering our combat operations and the heroin poppy - agricultural based economy.
Another major factor making this war untenable is the lack of leadership by President Obama including a failed foreign policy based on appeasement and apology. Rather than invoke fear in our enemies, the Islamic terrorists, he has emboldened them. This is not a formula for success.

August 01 2010 at 3:24 PM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply
ugrantme18

Lets See: Vietnam: 20 years, 500,000 U. S. troops in country, 58,000 U. S. casualties, 300,000 U. S. wounded, Justification: the red menace/communism will take over the world/aka the domino theory. As one who served there for 13 months, 2/67-3/68; I believed the whole package: hook, line and napalm.

Iraq/Afghanistan: 9 years, 150,000 U. S. troops in countries, 5,000 U. S. casualties, thousands wounded, Justification: weapons of mass distraction (oops i mean destruction in Iraq, and terrorists living in Afghanistan)

In 1955 Pete Seeger wrote, "Where have all the flowers gone?", and it ends with the following phrase:
"When will we ever learn?"
Obviously, 55 years later, we have not learned anything.

August 01 2010 at 2:00 PM Report abuse +7 rate up rate down Reply
carol and sandy

There's alot to be learned in the history of the American Indian Wars. Until the Army enlisted Indian scouts, they could'nt even find a hostile let alone fight them. Until we turn some Taliban and use them to seek the others out, we'll be sitting in some fort. Patton correctly pointed out that fortifications are monuments of the stupidity of Man. Wars our usually won by bringing your foe to battle at your terms not waiting for anybodies confort level to be right. We Americans seem to be lacking in historical knowledge especially our own.

August 01 2010 at 1:59 PM Report abuse +5 rate up rate down Reply
Mario

Sgt Bowles, you are in Afghanistan for the wrong reason. With that attitude of KILL, you should be rotated out and sent home! I am not impressed with Daniels either. This so-called war is 9 years too long! Mission is not going to be accomplished! Worst yet, many of these soldiers are coming home with alot of PTS.
The Taliban are not going away! They will be back and will continue to fight until they resume control. What will we have gained? Alot of deaths on both sides!

August 01 2010 at 1:57 PM Report abuse +3 rate up rate down Reply
2 replies to Mario's comment
matthew

Yeah, Victoria, and remember the country Iraq was invading was Iran, the country that had deposed their Shah of Western Oil Corps; so whose side of that part of the oil war was the US on at that time? So, to, number one: PROTECT THE TROOPS, and, number two:UPLIFT HUMAN DIGNITY: somehow an agreement has to be as to how the Afghan region will help with worldwide oil distribution. As the article states: A "Circle Road" is near completion; after that I'm sure corridors of security for some pipelines will become solidified -- It doesn't have to be with another 2-3 years of The Troops playing IED Roulette on these end of the road patrols from FOBs in the Wild West of Afghanistan. PROTECT THE TROOPS, HELP END THE OIL WAR(S).

August 01 2010 at 5:30 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
matthew

What do you mean "come back"? There will be no "coming back". The New And Improved Surge is only partially in place, by the time it's fully in place and with Mission Accomplished: The central circle road and other infrastructure will be completed, then a deal as to, and with, the surviving leaders of the time, it can be(the pipeline distribution goodies) if everyone cooperates; hopefully everyone cooperates, or else it will be put upon Obama to come up with a "deal they couldn't refuse..." -- can't you help come up with a way to do this without the Body Bags Filled With US Troops, and the graves filled with bodies from innocent Civilians caught in the crossfire?

August 01 2010 at 5:43 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
sasha

Some of us never wanted a war in Iran or Afghanistan. In Iraq we were taking out a petty dictator who had once been our friend but had turned uppity. Because of 9/11 we went in and bombed Afghanistan even though most perpetrators of 9/11 were from Saudi Arabia. Now the liberals are mad at Obama because he has not ended the conflict in Afghanistan and the conservatives would have been mad if he had. Unfortunately, we just cannot afford these wars anymore. Congress really should rein in the ability of a President to go off to war, especially one in which we were not directly attacked. It is so ironic that something as useful as health care reform is given months of deliberation, yet going to war seems to be done so precipitously. For now, get out of Afghanistan, but we do have to ensure the Taliban can no longer come into power.

August 01 2010 at 1:06 PM Report abuse +6 rate up rate down Reply
2 replies to sasha's comment
Susan

@Victoria....It is not the United States place to police the world. Saddam had NOTHING to do with 9-11. As far as Al Qaeda's second in command being killed there...Al Qaeda was not in Iraq until AFTER our former President decided to make a pre-emptive strike on that country. And yes, Congress did vote to go to war with Iraq, but they did so because of false information they were given at that time.

August 01 2010 at 3:35 PM Report abuse +4 rate up rate down Reply
kingnus

Susan, RIGHT ON!

August 02 2010 at 4:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Politics Daily

  • Comics
robert-and-donna-trussell
CHAOS THEORY
Featuring political comics by Robert and Donna TrussellMore>>
  • Woman UP Video
politics daily videos
Weekly Videos
Woman Up, Politics Daily's Online Sunday ShowMore»
politics daily videos
TV Appearances
Showcasing appearances by Politics Daily staff and contributors.More>>