Hot on HuffPost:

See More Stories

Peace Corps Turns 50 Amid Charges of Rape, Murder and Cover-Up

4 years ago
  0 Comments Say Something  »
Text Size
On the night of March 11, 2009, a 24-year-old Peace Corps volunteer named Kate Puzey was tied up and knifed on the front porch of her house in West Africa. Her throat was cut. She was killed the way you would slaughter a goat, Puzey's cousin told ABC's "20/20" in a Jan. 15 broadcast. Kate Puzey was the 23rd volunteer to be murdered in Peace Corps history.

The killing took place just days after Puzey e-mailed her Peace Corps supervisors about a fellow teacher and Peace Corps employee. He was not an American, but rather a villager, or Host Country National. Puzey believed he was raping the female students at the school where they taught. Puzey asked that her report remain anonymous, for obvious reasons. But it just so happened that a relative of the accused teacher was employed by the local Peace Corps office. Click below to watch video:

At first Puzey's parents were reluctant to blame the organization their daughter loved. But over time they grew frustrated with the Peace Corps' stonewalling. It did not help matters when their dead daughter's belongings were unceremoniously delivered in a cardboard box.

Gang rapes and death threats to female Peace Corps volunteers have in the past been met with apathy from the Peace Corps, according to the victims interviewed by ABC. In August 2009, President Obama replaced the previous Peace Corps director with Aaron S. Williams. Just prior to the airing of the ABC investigation, the Peace Corps released a statement assuring the public that Williams improved the organization's response to sexual assault and other crimes.

As for the murder of Kate Puzey, the Peace Corps had no comment: "Peace Corps does not have a role in the ongoing investigation, but we have been assured that the Benin government is supporting the legal process necessary to conclude the investigation and begin a trial. The Department of State and the FBI have been working with the Benin authorities."

Good luck with that. In a 2004 study, Benin was found to be the "most corrupt out of 95 countries analyzed."

Even Peace Corps defenders acknowledge the problems inherent in serving a developing country. One former volunteer wrote: "Peace Corps hires a lot of HCNs (Host Country Nationals) and there are usually a lot of bureaucracy involved in these countries. Firing bad employees is often very difficult and has to be handle extremely delicately (as in Kate's case)."

Viewers of the ABC show are outraged: "The stunning thing I learned from that report was that over 1,000 female volunteers have been sexually assaulted or raped over the past decade. ... The administration had successfully just swept it under the carpet. This ... [suggests] to the bad guys that if you rape our women, we will not make a fuss and will hush it up for you. The appropriate response should be exactly the opposite – a timely and forceful, loud response to the host nation that such thing will not be tolerated. None of this 'we cannot comment since it is still under investigation' ... over two years later! Shame on the Peace Corp bureaucrats!"

Writes a volunteer now serving in West Africa: "It eats at me every single day that I have children being molested in my schools and feel like I can't say anything about it for fear of backlash or, obviously, worse. Kate was well-integrated in her community, had that 'wall' of protection, but in the end, in this culture, murder for the sake of reputation isn't out of the question."

The commenter goes on to criticize the bureaucratic response of the Peace Corps in the Puzey case, as observed on the ABC program. "Sometimes you just need to fall on your sword, even if you can't directly pinpoint the mistake."

This kind of spotlight could not come at a worse time, just as Congress comes down with an acute case of cut-spending fever. The annual budget of the Peace Corps is $400 million. And this year, the Peace Corps turns 50. Maybe it's not such a bad time to take stock.

The Peace Corps was born at end of World War II. The idea was compelling: Young Americans would travel to developing countries and serve as "missionaries of democracy." Sen. Hubert Humphrey introduced a bill in 1957, and on March 1, 1961, President John F. Kennedy signed the order. A few months later, the first group of volunteers left for Africa, and almost immediately the controversies began. Volunteers in Nigeria stood accused of espionage, were sequestered, and ended up resorting to a hunger strike.

The sad case of Deborah Gardner is the stuff of film scripts. In point of fact, journalist Philip Weiss wrote a book about her. "American Taboo: A Murder in the Peace Corps" was published in 2004. The following year his story, "Stalking Her Killer," appeared in "New York" magazine.

In 1976, Gardner was known as the prettiest girl in the Peace Corps. Rightfully so. She taught high school on an island in the South Pacific. She was stabbed 22 times by Dennis Priven, a fellow volunteer who was stalking her. He pleaded insanity. Due to technicalities in the law, her killer not only went free, he ended up with a high-paying job in the Social Security Administration. He retired at the age of 51, probably with a nice pension.

If we can't even protect our own volunteers in these remote corners of the world, what are we doing there? Although the majority of former volunteers consider their time in the Peace Corps to be a highlight of their lives (and would do it again) we've come a long way from the "ugly American" days of the 1950s. Besides being a resume enhancer and surefire pickup line, to what purpose is the Peace Corps today?

Fifty years ago, ecotourism did not exist. "Lonely Planet" did not exist. Global Crossroad and Volunteer Abroad did not exist. Now you can teach English as a second language, after making contacts at Dave's ESL Cafe. You can immerse yourself in a culture, and put some muscle into spreading kindness wherever you go.

Kate Puzey told her parents that if anything happened to her in Africa, they should take comfort in the fact that she was doing exactly what she wanted to do. She's not the first, and she won't be the last to give her life in service. (RIP Cheryl Beckett, Daniela Beyer and Karen Woo, International Assistance Mission volunteers murdered in Afghanistan last year).

In the last decade the American military has moved toward the Peace Corps model. Hearts and minds, schools and bridges.

In a 1986 interview, Peace Corps founding director Sargent Shriver, who was hospitalized Monday, described his organization's raison d'être this way:
When [Gen. Augusto] Pinochet came into power a lot of Peace Corps volunteers were in Chile and they started protesting Pinochet and writing letters to newspapers. I was criticized in Washington for the actions of these volunteers. My response was that we should rejoice that we are the only country in the world that had the vision to send abroad people who are not under government control. Instead, they are independent free-standing human beings. I maintain that they are the greatest advertisement for the American system of government that there is in the world, they are worth a thousand Coca-Cola signs. There is no better advertisement for what this country stands for than an individual Peace Corps volunteer walking down the street unarmed, wearing the same clothes that the people do, eating the same food, living the same life, and being there as an independent free-standing person who believes in democracy and who is compassionate to his fellow man.
Such a sentiment dovetails perfectly with 21st-century ideals of tolerance and global cooperation. Maybe it's time to recognize that peace and war are not on opposite sides of the spectrum. In some countries, we can make peace instead of war. In other countries, perhaps we'd best not send our daughters unless we send soldiers with them.

Follow Donna Trussell on Twitter.

Our New Approach to Comments

In an effort to encourage the same level of civil dialogue among Politics Daily’s readers that we expect of our writers – a “civilogue,” to use the term coined by PD’s Jeffrey Weiss – we are requiring commenters to use their AOL or AIM screen names to submit a comment, and we are reading all comments before publishing them. Personal attacks (on writers, other readers, Nancy Pelosi, George W. Bush, or anyone at all) and comments that are not productive additions to the conversation will not be published, period, to make room for a discussion among those with ideas to kick around. Please read our Help and Feedback section for more info.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum Comment Moderation Enabled. Your comment will appear after it is cleared by an editor.


Filter by:

I'm currently serving in Africa. Whenever something like this happens to a Volunteer we are all incredibly sadden by it as we are a big family. No one tries to ignore what's happened or forget what's happened. But people have to realize that this is the reality. It's the reality where I live, where the Volunteers in other regions live and where you live. No Volunteer enters service completely naive and unaware of the possible dangers of being the foreigner. Also, we are given self-defense just before we're sworn in and if something happens to a Volunteer they are given the choice of pressing charges or not. I feel incredibly confident in the staff of my host country and in DC. What's really sad is that 50 years after its birth instead of highlighting the great things about Peace Corps and what it's done for the developing countries it serves and for America, one show can persuade so many ignorant people to immediately disdain the organization. I love my job, I love my community and I love the experiences I am having here. I wish you all could enjoy the experiences Volunteers have during service.

February 07 2011 at 4:20 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

It is disturbing that the Peace Corps would push this issue under the carpet essentially burying it. Very sad.

February 03 2011 at 3:50 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

400 million a year. For what. The first group went to Africa fifty years ago. Have they done any good? Africa is a screwed up continent and they need to manage themselves.

January 24 2011 at 5:04 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

I'm a 25 year old female in the Marine Corps and my sister is a 26 year old Peace Corps Volunteer. From us being from opposite sides of the spectrum, I can understand both sides of the issue. We need volunteers to go to other countries and show them that we aren't as bad as they think we Americans are and we need volunteers to go to other countries and protect our freedoms. But why can't we mix them together?
As this article said, the America military has already started to look towards the hearts and minds of the country that we're in. We know that we aren't fighting the civilians and we try to show them that we care by giving the children candy or helping out in their community. We are slowly but surely gaining their trust and they often help us find the "bad guys".
If the American military can train us how to help, then why can't the Peace Corps train the volunteers how to fight?
As a female, I was excited to learn how to defend myself. We're taught to use the weight and leverage of our opponent against them and how to disarm a person holding a knife or a gun. I'm am happy to say that I have never needed to use these techniques in the real world but I am nonetheless glad that I learned it.
Just because the Peace Corps Volunteer is there on a peaceful mission, doesn't mean that's how she will be treated.

January 23 2011 at 9:34 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Peace Corps volunteers are taught how to behave in their adopted country. They are not taught how to defend themselves. After living in a small town in South American near the border with regular drug traffic and kidnappings my daughter asked her superiors to take her out. They suggested that she give it more time. I was ready to hire a black helicopter to get her out. She is finally home without good memories about working for the Peace Corps. Parents beware!

January 22 2011 at 8:38 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

As a currently serving Peace Corps volunteer it is clear to me that many people do not understand what Peace Corps is really about. Those who say it should be disbanded and not funded probably don't know anyone who has served. Peace Corps is an amazing organization that has flaws, like every other organization out there.

Before joining the Peace Corps I knew a few women who had been raped or attacked while serving. Unfortunately I know many more women who have been raped or attacked at home in America. And for those of you who say that all of these rapes are prosecuted in America, obviously you are unaware of reality. It is all to common in American and around the world for the victim to be blamed. However, in my experience in my service I have never felt threatened and have the fullest confidence in the safety and security officer here.

We know what we are getting into when we join the Peace Corps. We are informed of the risks and hardships that we will face. But still we chose to go and show the world how amazing American can be when its at its best. We are also free to return home at any time during our service if we choose. Stop calling us naive and idealists and learn a little about what we actually do instead of basing your opinions on the horrible experiences of a few. While I am in no means discrediting what the women and families have been through (like I said, I personally am friends with women who experienced this) I don't think its fair to discount the work we are achieving in our service.

January 22 2011 at 6:50 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

Wow..the headline "It's the unemployment stupid" doesn't reek of any bias...does it? Totally irresponsible and ridiculous on the part of AOL!
I am tired of the propaganda...this country is going to hell in a handbasket!

January 21 2011 at 11:39 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

I entered Peace Corps service on my 55th birthday, six months after retirement as a medical school professor. My time as a PCV was two of the most enriching and enlightening years of my life. Because of what I gained during these years, I have dedicated my time and resources to other volunteer work, including seven times to African and Asian countries to fight poliomyelitis, twice to Latin American countries related to healthcare needs and, more recently, two trips to assist with water and sanitation needs in Africa - for the latter of which at age 70, I have just spent the last two weeks. I have provided the foregoing introduction to say how sorry I feel for Carpentersmokie, Kryptkiker, dwarner513, spiritusa, moondogfour, Cia Italiani, Joseph, Jarsd43 tenaclark and wolfe; each of whom express such a narrow perspective of human livelihood and other conditions in countries served by Peace Corps. I did not see the 20/20 program, so I cannot assess the perspective presented on the show mentioned.
Peace Corps is without a doubt one of the treasures of American society (though there are many more). Yet, we all must recognize that it is not suitable for everyone and for those who do enter, it cannot guarantee a perfect life. For those who are openminded, please join me in lobbying for an expanded Peace Corps.

January 21 2011 at 1:49 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

I agree with dwarner513 the Peace Corp should be disbanded

January 20 2011 at 12:13 AM Report abuse -3 rate up rate down Reply

Disband the "Peace" Corps. This is not Constitutionally allowed and should not be funded by tax payer money.

America and Americans first.

January 20 2011 at 12:04 AM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply

Follow Politics Daily

  • Comics
Featuring political comics by Robert and Donna TrussellMore>>
  • Woman UP Video
politics daily videos
Weekly Videos
Woman Up, Politics Daily's Online Sunday ShowMore»
politics daily videos
TV Appearances
Showcasing appearances by Politics Daily staff and contributors.More>>